Sal's site
In an age of endless streaming and instant gratification, a dusty, warbly plastic format finds new life at Champaign’s Exile on Main St.

The air inside Exile on Main St. in downtown Champaign is warm and welcoming on a chilly Saturday afternoon in February. Acoustic guitar chords and raw, heartfelt poetry readings drift through the aisles as WEFT 90.1 FM records the proceedings live.
Exile is hosting “Give a Little: A Benefit for Imerman Angels,” a cancer fundraising event that has drawn a respectable crowd to watch local singer-songwriters deliver laid-back Americana sets.
Surrounding the black, record-shaped stage where the performers stand is the eclectic, lived-in inventory that has kept loyal music lovers returning to Exile since it opened in 2004. The shop is a treasure trove of physical media and pop-culture artifacts: crates of used vinyl, retro video games, soy candles, vintage shoes, and a display of candy bars sitting near the register for good measure.
And tucked among the racks, Exile now carries “infinitely more tapes” than it used to, according to store owner Jeff Brandt.
“When we first opened 12 years ago, we didn’t have any tapes,” Brandt says behind the counter as customers mill about between musical acts. “Nobody came in asking for them. But over the last six or so years, people started asking for them more frequently. I used to only take them as donations because they sold so rarely. Now, things I used to price at 99 cents people will actually pay for. Depending on what it is, they’ve really gained value.”
Brandt’s front-line observations mirror a broader national trend. Industry data shows magnetic tape experiencing a surprising resurgence. While sales figures remain a fraction of vinyl’s massive revival, cassette purchases spiked by a staggering 74 percent in a single year as music fans sought out tangible, budget-friendly physical releases.
Why the sudden appetite for a format once left for dead? Brandt thinks it boils to the tactile joy of collecting. Cassettes offer an aesthetic, hands-on appeal similar to vinyl, but with an indie, do-it-yourself ethos. Many local and underground bands now release cassette runs bundled with digital download codes, turning the humble tape into a collectible keepsake.
Finding Gems in the Stacks
Among those enjoying the music at Exile is 26-year-old Champaign resident Brian Dunn. Standing next to his girlfriend, Melissa, the towering, six-foot-two Dunn wears a well-loved pink jacket and blue sweatpants, nodding his head in rhythm with the acoustic acts.
Between sets, Dunn—a dedicated cassette enthusiast—scans the tape racks looking for treasures. He emerges with three: Jubilee by local outfit Hot Cops!, 4 Songs by Nectar, and Sir Mix-A-Lot’s 1988 hip-hop classic, Swass.
Dunn is especially thrilled with the Sir Mix-A-Lot find, noting that vintage hip-hop tapes are increasingly hard to come by at Exile, where he digs through the bins every two weeks. As the assistant manager at WEFT 90.1 FM, Dunn hosts Cassette Cacophony every Monday morning from midnight to 2 a.m. While late-night commuters drive around listening to satellite radio or algorithmic playlists, Dunn spins tracks live on air directly from magnetic tape.
Possessing an easy smile, tousled hair, and a cheerful demeanor, Dunn modestly insists he isn’t the walking music encyclopedia people assume he is. He’s simply a dedicated supporter of local shows who started buying tapes at merch tables years ago to back C-U bands.
“I just started growing this collection,” Dunn says, “and the original point was simply to support these local artists.”
While he takes pride in curating an eclectic mix for Cassette Cacophony, Dunn is quick to clarify that he doesn’t overly romanticize the format. Tapes wear down. The plastic housing cracks. The brown ribbon inside can slacken or snarl, and cuing up a specific track live on the radio is an analog headache compared to clicking a digital file.
On the flip side, cassettes are surprisingly resilient. You can toss them in a backpack, play them in a beat-up car stereo, and if one breaks, replacing it doesn’t break the bank.
More importantly, the format changes how a listener interacts with the art.
“It forces you to listen to music in a totally different way,” Dunn says. “You don’t get that instant gratification of skipping tracks. You really have to listen to albums as a whole, from front to back.”
“It kind of forces you to listen to music in a different way. You don’t get that instant gratification. You really listen to albums as a whole, from front to back.”
-Brian Dunn
Character Over Perfection
Onstage, singer Cole Rabenort of the band The Fights finishes a soulful acoustic set, his raspy, powerful vocals invoking the grit of classic country. Between songs, Rabenort reflects on a relative he never met, but whose memory endures through a weathered photograph and family stories passed down through generations. He calls that kind of human continuation “transcendental.”
In a world dominated by invisible cloud streaming, the persistence of cassette tapes feels almost as improbable. The pre-owned tapes lining Brandt’s shelves—spanning everything from Louis Armstrong and Metallica to Jewel—were once cherished by music fans a generation ago. That emotional connection hasn’t vanished; it’s simply been rediscovered by a new wave of listeners.
“I like it when things have a little more character,” Dunn says, holding up his newly acquired Sir Mix-A-Lot tape with a grin. “This cassette is a little grody, a little dusty. It’s probably gonna have some pops and hiss when I play it. And I like that. To me, that’s cool.”
Photos and videos by Sal Nudo
This piece is included in the book Far From Mars: Nine Creative Nonfiction Stories Featuring People and Places in Champaign-Urbana.
